|
Reviews and
Raves
Queensland Journal of Music
Education
A 'must have' for
your rock music unit.
As the name implies these
texts address those styles which are not always dealt with
to any great extent in our school library resource books.
With opportunities for activities such as listening ,
composing, performing and improvising retro rock can be
taken as a complete teaching package for a unit of work or
could be used for single lessons. The authors have included
teachers' notes with helpful ideas. Having recently searched
with much frustration for more detailed information about
some of these styles and matching them up with musical
examples, I would have found this package a welcome
teaching resource with its information and quiz section,
appropriate arrangements in score form for young players and
recorded examples. At the end of each style description
there is a list of CD's or exponents of the style so that a
school could select a set which would match the styles. The
short quiz serves as a bank of fairly straight-forward
knowledge based questions which teachers could build on for
more extended analysis using application type questions
relating to the scores in Part B.
The authors have composed
the ten pieces for performance to demonstrate each style and
each one is scored for instruments available among players
in most classrooms. Some of the rhythms have syncopations
which students frequently hear in popular music and others
have a straight four to the bar. The simplicity of these
would allow for improvisation, imitation and variation as
the authors suggest. The scores vary as to the focus of the
instrumentation which would require expertise from at least
one section to hold the piece together well in performance.
At the same time they allow for a spread of skills among the
players with the more able ones doing the variations and
improvising over simple patterns. The graphic chart for the
arrangement on the recording can be reorganised so that
students can decide themselves who plays which part in the
cycle of repeats of the eight bars. These texts would be
excellent for middle school classes up to Years 9 or 10 and
could be used for all aspects of classroom activities,
varying the instrumentation, with effective results.
This is an inexpensive,
excellent resource package which you should consider adding
to your library not only for a unit of extended study but
also for those 'one off' lessons when you need some material
for performing, composing or listening activities or all
three!
Retro rock: Exploding Art
Music Publications. Three components: Part A Style Guide,
Part B Rock Scores and CD
Marj Milliken
QJME, Vol.6 (1) 1999. pp.65-66
New Zealand Society for Music
Education
It is obviously
designed for Years 7 - 10 (Forms 1 - 4), but looked like it
might just work with younger children as well. It's an
instrumental programme which relies to some extent on the
availability of tuned percussion instruments, but parts are
also written for Bb and Eb instruments, so you can use it
with clarinets, trumpets, strings, keyboards, and tuned
percussion. That makes it a versatile package for a wide
range of school situations.
The format of the package
is well conceived, with plenty of information for teachers
covering historical background, musical descriptions, and a
discography for each style. Of greatest appeal to me was the
simplicity and usability of each arrangement, and the
integrated approach of the whole package. There are
opportunities for improvisation, focussed listening, aural
training and structural analysis, research, and the
opportunity to consider the various styles in their social
context and period (which will ideally suit a strand of the
new Arts Curriculum due out in early 1999).
The acid test is how well
it works in the classroom. . . I tried Glitter Glam with the first school and it
worked! ... The piece worked because the contemporary sounds
of the accompaniments had immediate appeal, with their
overdrive guitars, drums, and synth timbres. It worked
because it was simple. . . . The melodies are not too long,
and they are catchy. It's a concept which is sort of
neo-Orff, or post-Orff, if you like.
I left a copy with a
couple of [classroom primary] teachers to see how they would
manage without my direct input. One related later that .
. it was the combination of repetitiveness that made
it accessible, and the variety of arrangements which made it
interesting, which drew them [uninterested students] into
playing along with the rest of the class. The other teacher
reported that the piece he had used was very popular with
the children as well.
The "rock scores" are
clearly written . . are accurate and easily followed.
I hope the authors consider producing a second volume at
some stage in the future. . . . It's very workable as is for
the years 7 - 10 in the hands of any teacher with basic
music literacy.
Selections from a review
by Paul Wheeler
NZSME Journal No. 48,
September 1998, pp. 24-26
The Australian Society for Music
Education Journal
"These two books and
CD are a great initiative by Brown and Dillon. The books
cover the 'alternative' styles of Glam Rock, Jazz Rock,
Rockabilly, Disco, Psychedelic Rock, Art Rock, Ska, Zydeco,
Hip Hop, and Latin Rock. Each style is approached in a
similar manner. In Part A: Background to the style, A Brief
musical description to the style, Sample Discography, Style
Quiz and Score and Listening Quiz (with reference to the CD
and Part B scores). Part B provides scores and parts
for the ten selected 'alternative' rock styles with rock
band accompaniments on the CD. For each piece there are both
tuned and untuned parts.
The Introduction and Notes
for the Teacher provide valuable assistance in the vast
range of possibilities that this set offers. The set
provides a resource for classroom music and/or junior
ensembles. It provides material for students to gain
an understanding of the development of style in rock music
through playing, study and reflection. It is refreshing to
find writers that are willing to provide photocopy rights
for school use. The possibilities available for the use are
a great feature of the set. This set would make a welcome
addition to the library of any teacher."
David Forrest -
Melbourne, Australia
First impressions from New
Zealand
"At last I've had
a chance to try a bit of Retro Rock with some country
children, just last week. I really like the concept,
especially for lower secondary students, but wasn't sure how
well it would go with a younger age group. I had the chance
to put Glitter Glam into action with some 9 - 11 year olds,
and they really took to it. The contemporary sound of the
accompanying track appealed in the first two
seconds."
Paul Wheeler -
Dunedin
Methodist Ladies College -
Creative uses!
"THANK
YOU!!!!!
The books arrived today,
and they are FABULOUS! Exactly what I needed, and the
scores will be terrific. I already have plans to
collaborate with our Art Specialist and Dance Specialist in
a rendition of "ART ATTACK" with somehow enacting the whole
'Pictures' thing. Thanks again,"
Methodist Ladies College -
Perth, Australia
If you'd like to review
Retro Rock for your music education journal, then
drop us
a line.
|