|
About Sound Reflections
To the teacher
Sound Reflections focuses and organises the music student
by allowing them to note all the tasks and ideas that are
often forgotten or lost in practical musical activities. It
encourages regular and critical thinking about music
activities, leading to a deeper understanding.
Reflective journal and diary
combined
Included in the book is space for writing about
instrumental activities, practice, homework, progress
reports, and critical self-analysis. Sound Reflections is a
way of keeping organised, focusing on individual learning
progress, and having a dialogue with students in a private
and reflective way. For classroom and band music programs
there are pages designed for occasional reflection about
Performing (presenting, realising and demonstrating),
Creating (composing, arranging and improvisation), and Music
Research (musicology assignments, analysis and sociology
projects). Each of these provides space for thoughtful
writing and criticism of these kinds of musical activity.
These questions are meant as a guide only and serve as a
checklist and method of reflective thinking that we hope
will become a habit for the young critical music student.
Monitoring and assessment
tool
For teachers and parents, Sound Reflections can be used
to record the instrumental and/or classroom progress of the
student and provide for assessment-feedback through progress
reports. Students can then read back over their experiences
and write a summary to which the teacher/parent may respond.
Answers to the Performing, Creating, and Research reflection
questions can help illuminate the students understanding of
their music study; and when reviewed by a teacher, lead
toward more informed feedback and assessment. This can be
used as a method of assessing the critical and aesthetic
development of the student and serves as valuable feedback
on all of the music experiences of the student.
Assists thinking and
learning
Sound Reflections is a 'notebook with an attitude' and
does encourage students to collect all their musical
thoughts in the one space. Sound Reflections helps students
to think about the music they are making and the music they
have made and to be critical and reflective of all music; it
also provides a bridge between all the musical activities
and people in a student's life that are so often separate
and seemingly unrelated.
Aspects of music
The aspects of music (often called elements or
dimensions) are outlined in a section towards the back of
Sound Reflections (p.30). This section will help student to
think about how music is constructed, will aid
familiarisation with the aspects of music, and will provide
words and concepts that aid writing about music in Sound
Reflections.
Music Talk
The Music Talk section is a glossary of musical terms. It
can be used to clarify the meaning of musical terms as they
arise in reading or conversation. It can be browsed through
to expand musical vocabulary, which increases the range and
accuracy of comments made about music in Sound Reflections.
Space is included for students to add their own terms and
definitions.
Finding the time to
Reflect
To the teacher
"Activity and reflection
should ideally complement and support each other. Action by
itself is blind, and reflection impotent."
(Csikszentmihalyi,M. 1992. Flow: The Psychology
of Happiness. London:Rider. p.226)
When we first began to use Sound Reflections in our
ensembles and classrooms we found that we simply did not
have the time to stop our activity and talk and write about
what we had done. The activity was fun and engaging and the
students were motivated to be involved, and we felt that to
stop and write or talk about our music was a let down and
took away from the precious little time we had to make music
anyway. Surprisingly, it was students that told us in
interviews that the times that they gained the best
understanding and meaning from music activity was when we
had made the time to reflect and discuss our music making.
Students also valued the skill of being able to do this as
one which enabled them to respond to music in an enhanced
way, and with a richer understanding and meaning.
Consequently, we restructured our approach to how we used
our time so that reflection was not an additional activity
but an integral part of the learning environment.
In the classroom
- Reflection can be something that is done at the end
of a unit of work in performing, composing, or
researching-where students evaluate and reflect on each
activity.
- Combine a presentation session with reflection, where
students present some music made in class whilst others
reflect and criticise it.
- Reflection can be set as a homework exercise, keeping
a journal of activity.
- Reflection tasks can be used as an evaluation tool to
examine how well a student understands musical ideas.
- Collect reflection recorder at the end of each term
to get extra insight into student development and to
provide feedback via the Progress Report.
In the ensemble
- Set reflection as a regular homework/practice task.
- Have a five-minute reflection/journal session at the
end of each rehearsal.
- Set Performance Reports as homework after each
concert.
- Encourage verbal reflection; both as an ensemble and
in small groups about the music made and discuss ways in
which problems might be solved.
In the instrumental
studio
- Teacher and students use it to communicate and record
what needs to be done for practice.
- Students record problems in the classroom or
ensembles to remind them to ask their studio teachers.
- Use the book to communicate with parents or other
teachers. The Lesson Notes section only requires brief
notes and notation; it is a reminder 'music jotter'.
- Collect Sound Reflections from the students each term
to assist in report writing and to provide feedback via
the Progress Report pages.
"Reflection is not an additional activity, it is
what transforms music into music education."
Using Sound
Reflections
To the student
Lesson Notes
This section can be used for you or your teacher to write
comments, practice suggestions and notated instructions
during your instrumental lessons or music classes. This will
help you to remember what to practise between lessons, the
set homework activities, and to keep a record of your
progress and all the things you learn.
Progress Report
Use the Progress Report at the end of each term to think
back over the progress you have made as a musician. In this
report write down the music you have studied, scales and
exercises you have mastered, performances you have given,
compositions you have written, projects completed and exams
you have undertaken. Comment on the things that have
improved in your playing, and the things which require more
work. You can also write down important advice your teacher
has given. Give the Progress Report to your teacher to read,
so they can comment and help you further.
Performing Report
Use the Performing Report whenever you observe, or
participate in, a performance or presentation of music. This
section will help you to listen critically to a musical
presentation. Performing can encompass singing, playing an
instrument, presentation of computer sequences and
recordings in public, sound installations, and music as part
of theatre, film or multimedia viewing. Reflecting on a
presentation or performance involves judging it both as a
whole and also analysing its parts.
Use the Performing Report checklist to comment quickly
about your impressions during the performance, by circling
the level of achievement in each listed category. After the
performance complete the rest of the report. When we
criticise a performance we can do it subjectively, that is
how we feel about a performance, and objectively which
describes the musical aspects of performance. Ideally we
should reflect both subjectively, commenting on our feeling
about the music, and objectively, by looking deeper and
analysing why it has an 'effect' on us.
Creating Report
You should complete a Creating Report after each creative
task. Creative tasks can include writing songs, arranging
music, making soundscapes, or any other composing task. In
the Creating Report it is important to fill in all the
sections. All creative work begins with an idea. This 'idea'
is then developed using techniques, tools and processes. The
music is then organised into an arranged structure or form.
Any of the aspects of music can be varied to develop a
piece of music. For example, a simple 5-note guitar riff may
be developed simply by repeating it. Its dynamic and timbre
may be developed by adding a saxophone in unison. It may be
developed texturally by adding harmony in the form of chords
played by a synthesizer. What is important is that any of
the aspects of music can be used to develop ideas and can
also be considered when talking about music and how it is
created.
Research Report
A Research Report should be filled out after completing
each music assignment or project. It is important to fill in
each section of the Research Report. It will help you to
consider each aspect of your research assignments and
projects. Topics for a music project can be very broad and
may examine recordings, scores, musicians, and instruments
from various cultures and times. When thinking about music
projects it is useful to consider how the information was
gathered as well as the final product. In this way you learn
about the topic as well as how to more effectively gather
information for future projects.
"Reflection makes experience meaningful and
can turn activity into understanding and understanding into
learning."
|